TJ Wengert·
At six foot five and roughly 221 pounds, Robertson brings an intriguing physical profile, highlighted by a livelier arm than Carson Beck
and slightly better overall athleticism. From a pure mechanics and consistency standpoint, Beck is ahead of Robertson. His footwork is cleaner, and his play to play accuracy is more reliable. However, when it comes to pushing the ball downfield, Robertson offers more upside. He has the arm strength to stretch the field and attempt throws that Beck simply cannot make at this stage. The numbers reflect both the appeal and the concern. Robertson posted a 60. 2 percent completion rate, which jumps to 67. 2 percent when adjusted for drops, a cleaner indicator of true accuracy. He also recorded 25 big time throws, a strong total that speaks to his willingness and ability to challenge coverage. On the other hand, he threw 12 interceptions and logged 21 turnover worthy plays, easily the highest figure among the quarterbacks discussed. That combination paints the picture of a scattershot passer with questionable decision making. The reason Robertson gets the slight edge over Beck is tied to traits. The arm talent and athletic ability give him a higher theoretical ceiling, even if his floor is lower. At the same time, he is much further away from being a dependable NFL backup. His path forward requires significant refinement in processing, ball placement, and risk management. In short, Robertson is a tools based developmental quarterback. The upside is more enticing than Beck’s, but the journey to becoming a trustworthy option will be longer and far less certain.